
Zachary Quinto as Dr. Oliver Thredson in American Horror Story: Asylum. Photo by Frank Ockenfels and copyright of FX.
Six years ago, Zachary Quinto sent shivers up the spines of TV audiences with his portrayal of the superpowered serial killer Sylar in the NBC Sci-FI saga Heroes. Prior to that, the actor made his debut in the short-lived supernatural series The Others. He later guest-starred on such shows as CSI, Touched by an Angel, Charmed and Six Feet Under as well as appeared in the recurring role of computer expert Adam Kaufman in Fox’s clock-ticking 24. Quinto also played Sasan, the gay Iranian/American best friend of Tori Spelling’s character in her VH1 series So NoTORIous.
In 2009, the actor put his own (successful) spin on Star Trek’s iconic Vulcan character Spock in producer/director J.J. Abrams’ reboot of the feature film franchise. Quinto reprises his role in the upcoming Star Trek: Into Darkness. Last year, he played Chad Warwick, who died tragically in season one of FX’s American Horror Story. Quinto is back on the show this year and, in American Horror Story: Asylum, he plays psychiatrist Dr. Oliver Thredson, who is, in fact, the notorious serial killer “Bloody Face.”
Recently, the congenial and talented actor/producer enthusiastically participated in a conference call with me and other journalists to talk about his role on American Horror Story: Asylum as well as career in general. The following is an edited version of that Q& A. Enjoy!
When did you discover that Dr. Thredson was “Bloody Face?” Did you know from the beginning and, if so, did that inform your performance at all?
Zachary Quinto: Yes, I knew from the very beginning. It was part of the conversation that I had in the first place with (series co-creator/executive producer) Ryan Murphy about me coming back to the second installment of the show. It very much informed the character that I was building from the beginning.
As a result, I felt like my responsibility became to create a character that people could trust, or at least trust initially, and have some hope that perhaps he is actually the one voice of reason and sanity within this chaotic world. So it was actually more exciting for me to know from the beginning. It gave me more to play with as well as more to hold back and more secrets to keep.

Dr. Oliver Thredson (Zachary Quinto) in the season premiere of American Horror Story: Asylum. Photo by Frank Ockenfels and copyright of FX.
We’ve only seen a little bit of his evil thus far, but how is this character different from Sylar in Heroes? Is that something you were concerned about as far as audiences making comparisons between the two, and what is it that hooked you on really wanting to play this part?
ZQ: I think any time an actor revisits territory where they’ve been before, it can be a source of trepidation, as it was for me. However, part of the reason that I loved what this opportunity stood for was, and that I knew going in, is that I got to really build something. With Heroes, that character was built before I was ever attached to the show. There were eight episodes of anticipation that were built before you met “Gabriel Gray (Sylar)” in Heroes, but I had no participation or opportunity to sort of contribute to that. It was just a character being spoken about.
So with American Horror Story, it was really exciting for me to go in and, having all the beforehand information, actually be part of the process of creating a character. That, to me, was a difference. It was something that I thought, “Yes, that makes sense.” It also has a similar structure to the journey I had on Heroes, at least with introduction of the character, or the “reveal,” which proved very effective in that scenario and I felt I could really also serve this story in this particular innovation.
Also, this is more rooted in character and relationship, and less in the sort of peripheral elements like superpowers. I liked that this was grounded and real. That type of direction is something I’m always drawn to, and this isn’t a six-year commitment as it could be with another show. It’s self-contained and an immersion that I’m not going to be repeating or carrying on for an extended period of time. It’s something I got to contribute to as well as benefit from and grow and learn with. So I was really excited about all those elements.

Lily Rabe, Jessica Lange, Ryan Murphy and Zachary Quinto at the Prime Time Emmy Awards. Photo copyright of FX.
Now that we know Thredson’s very dark and dirty little secret, are we going to get into the psychosis behind the psycho and find out why he’s doing this, because he seems to be focusing a lot on Lana (Sarah Paulson) and her girlfriend Wendy (Clea Duvall)?
ZQ: The most recent episode) The Origins of Monstrosity really dives into a lot of the roots of the characters in the Asylum world. So yes, a number of things will become clearer and probably even more disturbing in the next couple of weeks.
You and Sarah Paulson have a good friendship off-screen; how does that dynamic impact the show’s themes, especially considering, like you said, things are only going to get darker from here.
ZQ: Well, I have a great deal of respect for Sarah as an actress, and it’s a rare and unique opportunity to show up to work with a really good friend. Oftentimes, friendships are formed on-set and through these kinds of experiences working together in such intimate and unusual ways, but it’s even a richer experience when you already have that foundation of friendship. There’s an implicit trust and sensitivity to each other as well as one another’s needs, instincts and individual process. It’s really a remarkable gift in a lot of ways. We’re also able to have more fun, I think, and laugh at a situation a little bit more. There’s less awkwardness to cut through, too.
So I think it strengthens the connection that the characters share, whether it’s friendship, torture, being/taking a hostage, etc. I mean, I love going to work anyway, no matter who I’m working with, but in particular with Sarah, it’s been great. I think she’s doing such wonderful work on the show and I also just love watching her character and the journey she’s taking. Lana has gone to so many extreme, challenging emotional places, and Sarah has done all that so beautifully and dynamically. So it’s been a joy for me, really, this whole experience.
In light of your character’s recent revelation, was everything prior to that a ruse, or is there a side of Oliver that deeply believes in the psychiatry part? I mean, one of the last things we saw him do before the big reveal was tell Sister Jude (Jessica Lange) that Charlotte had post-partum depression and recommended she shouldn’t go home, which was a smart move on his part. But again, was it all just blending in or does he believe in that?
ZQ: I feel that he definitely believes in it. Part of being a psychopath is an ability to dissociate from one reality and create another one completely. I think Oliver does that expertly. He’s very skilled, given his level of training, medical training and instincts.
That’s what allows him to get away with it for as long as he does. So yes, I think he does believe in it, which is kind of another layer of tragedy of the character. Oliver could have been something else. He could have made a more significantly positive contribution had he only re-channeled his traumas and energy.

Dr. Thredson (Zachary Quinto) in the Asylum episode "Tricks and Treats." Photo by Michael Yarish and copyright of FX.
Was your approach to playing your character different in Season Two of the show with Thredson/Bloody Face being more of a threat as opposed to Season One and playing Chad as a victim?
ZQ: Yes. I feel like last season’s story was just told in a different style. This year is a period piece and there are other considerations that go along with that, just in terms of characterization, I think. I don’t know how much it has to do with playing an antagonist this year rather than the victim. That’s all just circumstantial.
There are still a lot of psychological manipulations going on from one end that makes it a little bit more veiled, or always holding something back this season. But that’s just all fun. However, I just think of it in terms of who the person is and what’s driving him. Obviously those motivations were very different for Chad than they are for Thredson.
What can you say about the victims that Thredson is targeting? Obviously, they’re all women. What do they all have in common and what is it about them that make them his targets? Also, do you have any interest in returning for Season 3?
ZQ: So for the first part of that question; you’ll find out much more about that in the coming weeks, I won’t spoil it by being too specific, but it all traces back to one source of trauma that then sort of branches out to include all these unfortunate women.
As for your second question, I read today that the show got picked up for a third installment, which is very exciting. I’m so glad that it’s doing so well and people are really responding to it. FX has been amazing and so supportive and, I think, innovative in the stuff that they’re doing. It’s great to work there and be a part of it. I haven’t had any conversations with Ryan about what he’s thinking for the third season, so I have no idea.
I love my job and the people that I do it with and I always want that to be the case. So I know he has plans and if they involve me, I’m sure I’ll get a call at some point, but I don’t know anything about it yet. I’m just focused on getting through the rest of this season and moving onto the next phase of stuff that I have lined up.

Oliver (Zachary Quinto) and Sister Jude (Jessica Lange) in the Asylum episode "I Am Anne Frank, Part 2." Photo by Byron Cohen and copyright of FX.
Was your decision to do this series based on the fact that it’s not actually American horror, in so much as it focuses more on modern horrors in the world right now?
ZQ: I actually think it’s mostly uniquely American as far as the way that it’s structured in the certain instances and also in what it’s looking at. There are the sort of Catholic institutions in this country, in particular, and the social history of racism, homophobia, sanity, psychiatry, the idea of how to treat people who are mentally ill, etc. I think those are all very American ideas and concepts and the way in which we dive into them is also really American in the style of storytelling.
For example, the episode that aired a couple of weeks ago, episode five (I Am Anne Frank, Part 2), I thought Alfonso Gomez-Rejon, who directed it, did an incredible job. I was so inspired by his direction and the camera work. It felt like such a wonderfully composed episode. I think that is really somehow reflective of modern day-America and also where we’ve come from. That’s what excites me about the kind of show that we’re making as well.
Having been involved with Season One of American Horror Story, did (series co-creator/executive producer) Brad Falchuk and the others allow you to provide input into your new character in Season Two?
ZQ; Yes, I had a few conversations with Ryan and Brad before we started. Ryan and I discussed what he was thinking and I had some questions and a chance to contribute to what I would like to see. Once they get going, though, it’s like their engines just drive them and all of us forward in such surprising and unexpected ways. So the vast majority of that comes from them and actually brings the show to life. That’s how I see it.
You’ve played some very different characters – in Heroes there was a lot more to Sylar than met the eye. In Star Trek you played an iconic Spock, and now you’re playing a psychotic serial killer psychiatrist. What was/is your favorite and most fun character to play?
ZQ: That’s a good question. I feel like each one of those experiences was so profound and unique. The past six years has been just full of growth and creative fulfillment for me. It’s hard to sort of narrow it down one, because they are accumulative in a lot of ways. As far as the TV aspect of it goes, I would say that I feel more settled as I’m getting older and my experience of things feels kind of more complete.
So Thredson has been very satisfying to me in that regard. I just feel like I’ve been carrying more of my experience with me into my work and as I get older, that deepens naturally. That’s kind of cool, but I just like to do good work, or try to do good work with good people and I’ve been very, very lucky in that regard. As long as I continue, that’s all I could ask really.

Zachary Quinto at the American Horror Story Season Two Premiere Screening at Paramount Studios. Photo by Brian Dowling and copyright of FX.
We have seen your American Horror Story character become a big focal point with this big turnaround involving Bloody Face, but what are your other favorite storylines, outside of your own, on the show that you really are excited for people to find out more about?
ZQ: I love watching the Kit (Evan Peters) storyline; I think Evan is fantastic. I’m also really enjoying what Lily Rabe is doing with her character of Sister Mary now that she’s got the “devil” inside her. That’s such delicious stuff and she’s doing a great job with it. I can’t take my eyes off Jessica Lange, either. She’s so committed to her ferocity of instinct and extremely riveting and inspiring at the same time.
I love working with these people. I wish I had more to do with James Cromwell (Dr. Arthur Arden). I’ve never really crossed paths like the doctor in the asylum, but maybe there’s something to look forward to there. We’ll have to wait and see.
Did you always know that American Horror Story was going to be an anthology?
ZQ: No, I didn’t. When I did it the first time around, the timing of it worked out really well for me because Star Trek had gotten pushed, so I ended up having like a little bit of a window that I didn’t expect to have, and Ryan called to ask. I just thought it was going to be a couple of episodes and it ended up being four episodes last season. But I didn’t know what it would be, and then it was in the middle of that, that Ryan actually brought up the idea of the second season being entirely different.
That was the beginning of the conversations, which really intrigued me, obviously. I had been exploring the possibility of another specific job that would have been a more traditional sort of TV structure and it was really exciting in its own way. When Ryan presented the plan to me about this, there was no question that it was a bit more unique as well as exciting to me, and because of that, it made my decision pretty clear.
This season is more challenging, too, because I’m more of an integral part of it and there’s more work to do to help build my character’s arc because it’s a more extensive one. So therefore it’s more rewarding and more fulfilling in a way, because you’re really seeing something through from the beginning to the end. That’s cool and I’m having a good time with that.
As with the house in Season One of American Horror Story, the asylum is like a character on the series this year. Can you talk a bit about how the environment helps you get into character?
ZQ: That’s a great observation, because I think our production designer and the art department have done such an extraordinary job of creating this immensely oppressive, overwhelming environment, which does have actual characteristics depending on what part of the set you’re shooting in. I just think it’s a gold mine of information and opportunity for action and activities along the way, and makes such a full environment for us to work in.
It’s great, and that continues in the coming weeks because you get to see much more of the lair in which Lana is being held captive and where a lot of their scenes take place. Then there’s the hydrotherapy room and what that invokes and what happens in there as well as the bakery, the grand hallway, all the cells, the offices, the oppressive, concrete olive green kind of brown-beige and that overall institutional feeling. Growing up, I went to Catholic school and this really invokes a lot of the same imagery. The iconography and stuff with statues; I think all that is so well-realized in the world. I’m really grateful to the creative team behind that because they do remarkable work.
With the dark, and so intense, subject matter, how hard is it for you to step away from that when not on- set? How does this character have an emotional effect on you?
ZQ: It does to a degree, but I consider it my responsibility to myself to be able to discern the boundaries in my life. So I really try to separate myself as clearly as possible. As a trained actor, that’s part of what I learned how to do, too, as far as going to college and studying and cultivating a technique that allows me to enter some of these really complicated, psychological landscapes and not get lost in them. But yes, I certainly have outlets and various things I do in order to make sure that I stay grounded and clear. It’s also what’s kind of fun about it. I know I can let myself go in certain ways, because I won’t go off in other ways that are important.
How do you prepare mentally to play this dark, demented kind of role, and do you enjoy it or find it more of a challenge?
ZQ: It depends on the scene. There are different levels of preparation for different scenes in different kinds of work. So I have a combination of things that I do. I usually just find some solitude and quiet in a little corner of the set where there’s not a lot of traffic and not a lot of people around and do what it is I need to do. I listen to music a lot, if I need to get into a particular emotional space. I use that and other sort of stretching exercises as well as breathing and taking time to mostly be quiet and find that kind of stillness.
I think that’s important. I love playing characters that go to extreme places and I love to explore different kinds of psychological landscapes. So it’s ultimately a kind of fun, but it’s also complicated and colored by the depth of the nastiness of it at certain times as well. That can be a challenging part.
As noted above, photos by Frank Ockenfels, Byron Cohen, Brian Dowling or Michael Yarish and copyright of FX, so please no unauthorized copying or duplicating of any kind. Thanks!